3 Ways to Evaluate and Replicate Successful Advocacy Marketing Posts

evaluating your advocacy marketing posts

Last week we gave some pointers on how to increase your advocacy marketing program’s return on investment (ROI) by optimizing your social media imagery. This week, we’re going to continue our ROI conversation with some tips and insight into what performance metrics you should look for when evaluating your advocacy marketing posts.

Let’s get started. 

Choosing How to Calculate Advocacy Marketing ROI 

If you want to scale your advocacy marketing program’s success, you need to start by deciding the ultimate goal(s) of your program. What are you trying to achieve with your advocacy marketing efforts and how are you tracking a successful return on investment?

While every advocacy marketing program is different, most programs tend to calculate ROI one of two ways:

ROI Calculation Method #1: Direct Conversions

Essentially, the number of specific conversions attributed to advocacy marketing efforts. These conversions could be direct sales, coupon downloads, ticket sales, or any other specific user-action that a company is tracking.

The more conversions your program drives, the greater the return on your marketing investment.

ROI Calculation Method #2: Earned Media Value

In other words, what is the paid media value that your program has earned? If it’s typically costing you $2.50 per click on your paid digital media efforts and your program generates 1,000 clicks, then your earned media value on those clicks would be $2,500.

When calculating earned media value, be sure to also include all impressions/engagements earned as part of your total program earned media value calculations in order to determine the true value of your program.

Evaluating Successful Advocacy Marketing Posts

Once you’ve chosen your preferred method for calculating ROI, you can start evaluating your posts against that mark of success. 

Key Advocacy Marketing Post Evaluation Metrics

Share Rate

Perhaps the number one metric you should look at when evaluating your advocacy marketing posts, the share rate is the ratio that reflects the percentage of your advocates that have opted to share your content.

That is, how many of your advocates considered your content worthy enough to share.

The higher your share rate, the greater the indication that your advocates are resonating with your content.

Engagement Rate

While the share rate metric helps to evaluate how your content is resonating with your advocates, the engagement rate metric indicates how your shared content resonates with your advocates’ own social media following. 

The more engagements (likes/comments/shares) your shared content earns, the greater the indication that your extended audience finds your content valuable. 


Similar to the engagement rate, but slightly different, the click-through-rate measures the likelihood that someone is clicking through and consuming the content that is being shared. While engagements are fantastic and an important aspect of any advocacy marketing effort, clicks (especially if you’re ROI is tied to a direct conversion) are vital for driving action. 

Additional Metrics

While these three metrics represent the lion’s share of your evaluation efforts, there are dozens of other key performance indicators you can keep tabs on to further optimize your program. These include:

  • Email Open Rate
  • Video Views
  • Conversion Rate
  • Program Attrition 
  • Average Number of Shares per Advocate

Putting it All Together

As you start tracking this data (hint SocialToaster’s reporting dashboard track’s this information for you) you can begin to identify trends. Which posts are consistently showing the highest share or engagement rates? Which are driving the most clicks?

Do these posts share the same topic? Offer the same value?

Likewise, look for  the posts in your advocacy marketing program that have the lowest rates. Do they share anything in common?

Once you are able to start identifying which content is performing well, you can begin to optimize your posting schedule to include more of that specific type of content.

Test, Evaluate, Optimize, Grow

As you begin to identify content or posts that don’t perform, consider replacing those posts or post topics with new content to test. A successful program is one that evolves to meet the ever-changing expectations and needs of its advocates.

Once you begin identifying content that resonates with your audience, it’s time to scale that content type and create more content for your advocates to enjoy.

Ready to talk advocacy marketing ROI? Schedule a call today with one of our advocacy marketing specialists by sending us an email or by giving us a call at 855.62.TOAST! Not a SocialToaster customer? See what all the hype is about by scheduling a free demo of our award-winning platform.

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts
Leverage your Micro-Influencers and Everyday Fans
Download our newest white paper and learn the difference between working with a Micro-Influencer vs. Everyday Fans and how each can be leveraged to support your advocacy marketing and influencer marketing efforts.

Lets Get Started On Your Campaign

Would you like to connect with someone on our sales team to learn more about the SocialToaster platform and how it might add value to your business? Request a demo here or send us an email to sales@socialtoaster.com.